The Dictators in the Locker Room

22 Jun 2016
Part 28 of "Broken Democracy" series

The stray dog outside my window has been barking at a broken streetlamp for three hours. A completely useless exercise, howling at a machine that cannot hear, cannot care, and cannot be reasoned with. I sit here sweating into a cheap plastic chair, sipping a glass of lukewarm tap water that tastes faintly of rust and chlorine, watching this futile standoff. It feels identical to watching a citizen walk into a polling booth. I am just barking at broken streetlamps, praying the bulb will magically flicker back to life.

I vote for a man to represent my district, believing I am electing a voice. But the moment he secures his seat, he stops being a human being. He becomes a hollow vessel. The anti-defection laws strip him of his conscience, yes, but the real betrayal happens much earlier, long before the indelible ink on my finger even dries. It happens inside the walls of his own political party. I hear endless lectures about saving the democracy of the nation, yet I am forced to watch as dictatorial political parties run it. They are private, ruthless cartels. Feudal estates masquerading as public institutions.

When the municipal water tank runs dry and the pipes spit dust, the man I elected cannot speak up because his party high command forbids it. The "High Command"—a few untouchable figures sitting in an air-conditioned bunker in Delhi—dictates every move, every word, every vote. They are the master, and my representative is merely a compliant cog in their sprawling machine. I am governed by a handful of dictators who have never faced an honest internal vote in their entire lives. The cowardice of these politicians is staggering. They surrender their autonomy, their self-respect, their very souls, just to secure an election ticket. Cowards, every single one of them, terrified of crossing a dynasty or a central committee.

If I want to buy a decent coconut at the market, I inspect it. I shake it. I make sure it isn't rotten inside. Yet, I am expected to swallow entire political parties that are completely rotten at the core. A democratic country cannot be run by dictatorial parties. It is a mathematical and moral impossibility.

The Election Commission cannot just act as a referee for the final tournament; it must monitor the locker room. The only way I see to break this monopoly is by mandating audited, EC-monitored internal elections for party leadership.

If a political party wants to be recognized, if it wants the privilege of a symbol on the EVM, its leadership must be chosen by its own grassroots workers in a transparent, EC-supervised election. Not selected by "consensus" behind closed doors. Not handed down like a family heirloom along with the silver tea sets and the black money accounts. The Election Commission must audit their membership rolls and run their internal contests with the exact same rigor they apply to a general election.

If the people claiming they want to run the country cannot even run their own party democratically, they have no right to ask for my vote. Until the law forces the machine to democratize itself from within, the ballot box is just a suggestion box for slaves.